Sometimes it is impossible to tell whether I'm a really good parent or a really terrible one. Since I'm usually so busy with the day-to-day chaos of parenting while working full-time, I don't spend a ton of time thinking about this question, but occasionally something happens that makes me reassess everything I do as a mom. One of those times happened with Stow a month or so ago (BEFORE the concussion incident), and it came in the form of a writing assignment.
Stow doesn't love English class, and he does not love writing, so when he excitedly asked me to look at what he'd written for homework, I was taken aback. He told me they were supposed to write a story about feelings without using the word for the feeling. His feeling, he explained, was anger. When he showed me his computer, I was thrilled to see that he had written more than one or two sentences AND that he had done so without nagging from me or Ren.
Then I read what he wrote:
Nut War 2
Sir squirrel the 3rd
death 2012 august 3rd
from a falling nut
His last words were
“Those darn falling nuts”
Buy the 2nd novel for the rest of this nutty tale for only $10.99 Limited time, just don't get too nutty about it.
Now, what would YOU do? Your kid who hates to write has created an extended pun, using multiple sentences and decent spelling and grammar. Telling him to rewrite it would 1) meet instant resistance, and 2) risk the possibility of crushing his spirit. But you also know that his teacher will likely not find the humor in this exposition. Plus, you aren't sure what the assignment was but feel pretty certain this wasn't it.
What would have been the right response?
And, how would you have discussed it with your kid?
and once you determine.....
how you would have responded.....
scroll on down to hear the rest of the story.
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
Here's what I did. I'm not sure it was the right thing to do, but it was the only thing I could think of to do.
I told Stow I thought it was a brilliantly creative and funny story. I asked him to explain the assignment again and questioned whether he was sure he'd understood it. (He was). Then I pointed out that although I thought it was funny, I wasn't sure his teacher would. I reminded him that there is a time and place for certain humor and that it was up to him to determine whether he thought submitting it was appropriate. He responded by asking me, "Mom, it's just about a squirrel and his nuts. Why would the teacher get mad?"
He had a point, but also, the story was clearly not about THAT kind of nuts.
After reiterating that I was pretty sure this wasn't what the teacher was looking for and asking him to consider how she might feel reading it, I gave up because clearly his mind was set.
Plus, I was happy he'd done the assignment and didn't want to crush his creativity.
I forgot about the assignment for a few days. And then this arrived in my inbox:
Good morning,
I wanted you to be aware of the writing assignment Stow turned in. The assignment was to write about an emotion. The task was to "Show, Don't Tell" what the emotion would look like, sound like, feel like. Students also needed to include strong verbs. We worked on this for several days in class, going over examples, having class discussions, modeling both good and bad examples, and doing in-class practices.
[Copies and pastes "Nut War 2" in full]
We are going to have Stow redo this assignment, as how it currently is, will not receive many points. He wrote a creative story, rather than explaining the sensory details of the emotion he chose - mad.
Mrs. G. and I are also concerned about its appropriateness. The largest focus seems to be on "nuts." While he wrote it to be about squirrels, the way he describes everything is not appropriate.
*****
One of my close friends is convinced that Stow is on a secret mission to force teachers to write emails to me that include words that teachers don't normally say. I've gotten emails about things like "Merry Poopmas" (kindergarten) and appropriate and inappropriate uses of the word "bottom" (2nd grade). So when I told her about this, she just added it to the ongoing list of things Stow has forced adults to have awkward conversations about.